J
Jonny boy
Not necessary at all .Yes it matters return should be at the bottom so when the water cools it flows into the return
One of the biggest myths of small bore heating . TBOE doesn’t care what the configuration is and the so called “ traditional wisdom” of putting the return at the bottom or lower pipework is flawed.
Correctly as you state , as the hot flow gives up it’s heat it becomes less buoyant more dense and will sink , but there is no counter convective interaction and although the efficacy is improved with TBOE , it would improve further with Hot flow at bottom return at top . Why ? Because it created counter flow , which is far more efficient in mixing flows and therefore gives greater thermal efficiency and efficacy . Heat from the convective sense naturally wants to rise . It will of course give up heat becoming cooler and want to fall back down . If the hot feed is at bottom, it counter flows and blends far better . The remaining heat wants to rise anyway so it’s sensible to return from the top , not forgetting it’s still relatively hot and the useful heat exchange has taken place in the rad.
All large heat exchangers function with counter flow