Checking advice given re burst galvanised pipe

[Dreamy787]

A galvanised pipe on our property burst and water was seeping up to ground level. We dug and found where it burst [it's in the garden but the pipe eventually shoots off under the deck and house], called in a plumber who said he couldn't fix it that day due to other work but temporarily stopped the leakage using a tap fitting. He now reckons he has to dig up the entire line of piping right back to the main and replace it with copper piping. He hasn't given any reason for this and we suspect he's just trying to rip us off because he's also trying to convince us to also replace our hot water system which is working fine. Is there any obvious reason why he could not simply cut out the broken part of the pipe and replace it? Someone suggested that maybe galvanised pipes are not to standard and therefore can't be used. The house in located in NSW, Australia.

 

[ShaunCorbs]

Maybe he can’t thread and tap the galv line ?

 

[rpm]

@oz-plumber, one for you and your regs?

 

[Chuck]

One reason why you might want to replace the entire length is if the pipe is corroding internally. The leak could be a symptom of that and, if so, is going to be the first of many. Another might be that the current pipe is undersized for your property. Another might be local regulations. (I have no idea what regs apply in Aus.)

He hasn't given any reason for this and we suspect he's just trying to rip us off

TBH, you should get another plumber who you do trust. If that's how you feel you're never going to be happy with the current guy.

 

[fixitflav]

One reason why you might want to replace the entire length is if the pipe is corroding internally. The leak could be a symptom of that and, if so, is going to be the first of many. Another might be that the current pipe is undersized for your property. Another might be local regulations. (I have no idea what regs apply in Aus.)



TBH, you should get another plumber who you do trust. If that's how you feel you're never going to be happy with the current guy.

If he's going to replace it I'd have thought MDPE would be a better bet than copper.

 

[Chuck]

If he's going to replace it I'd have thought MDPE would be a better bet than copper.

In the UK, certainly, but it's Australia... They've got some flipping scary wildlife and there's probably some type of spider that digs up MDPE and uses it to build a web...

 

[Ric2013]

I agree that if the galv has failed in one place, it'll soon fail somewhere else. It would seem pointless to spend money on a repair that is likely to prove temporary.

Having said that, I would be concerned about using copper for supply pipe if the internal pipework of the house is galv (but perhaps the internal plumbing is already copper or plastic?).

 

[Dreamy787]

Maybe he can’t thread and tap the galv line ?

I did some googling and I think I understand. Yes, quite possibly he can't get a thread on the existing pipe.
[automerge]1591175111[/automerge]

One reason why you might want to replace the entire length is if the pipe is corroding internally. The leak could be a symptom of that and, if so, is going to be the first of many. Another might be that the current pipe is undersized for your property. Another might be local regulations. (I have no idea what regs apply in Aus.)



TBH, you should get another plumber who you do trust. If that's how you feel you're never going to be happy with the current guy.

Yes, I think it is corroding so I see that in the long run it is probably better to replace it. We used to have a wonderful plumber but he's now a building inspector. Unfortunately there aren't many plumbers in the area so it's slim pickings but I'll call someone else out, see how we go.

 

[SimonG]

Can you not speak to your old plumber, quick call just to put your mind at ease?