I have fitted one and it is of no different quality to the first generation magnacleans but it is sorely let down by not having an air bleed nipple on the lid. Venting means cracking the seal of the whole lid. Also the internal magnet is not as long as the filter unlike the magnacleans.The screwfix filter could be the best thing in the world it just doesn't look a quality product, the no nonsense branding lets it down badly.