Ah got you ok then if only the frost setting turns it off then yes more than likely needs replacing.
I thought you were going to say that when you turn it down to 3 it still stays the same temperature.
LOL.. I can see why you said that.
ps. I'm looking for a replacement TRV that has native 10mm fittings to the microbore.. I can find loads that are 15mm with 10mm reducers.. but then my current 10mm compression nut won't fit... you have to use the supplied 15mm type nut with them. the there is the need to cut off the olive (if you can) just to get the reducer kit installed... all of my rad piping is horizontal with 10mm elbows to the valve rather than straight up out of the floor.
Rather use a 10mm fitting.. any pointers/stockist/model?
Thanks again