Magnacleanse Power flush filter versus pumped machine

[ecowarm]

Thats what I think according to the Adey literature it can act as a stand alone unit utilizing the ch pump,but is that going to provide enough velocity to shift the magnetite sludge ,they seem to give the impression this thing is going to put Pump based units in the museum!it may have been better combined into a pumped unit.

I dont see how it can, best combined with P/F machine

 

[Spudhater]

Point taken on Pump...

If the rads are that bad i would advise the customer to change them, with the cost of "Power Flush" you can nearly change all the rads on a 3 bed semi.

The pipe work is normally not a problem.

The HV pump alone does not always break up the mag you forgot the vibrating drill!!!!

Cost £1500.00

or a rubber mallet £5.00

 

[WHPES]

I got one of the Fernox Magnom powerflush filters (I think it's called the Flush Buddy now or something similar) and it does a good job of cleaning out the magnetic debris. The only complaint is that it can be a bit of a pain to clean out.

 

[AFLT]

it is the same kit as my bro -in -law uses on his pumped machine..

They are marketing it as a stand alone cleaner, good idea in my view, i spoke to the rep at the Phex show and he said this is all you will need to clean all the "MAGNETIC" sludge..

I spoke to the Adey reps at Phex too and I wasn't impressed. I've been power flushing for years and can't see how the Magnacleanse will replace a flushing pump. You need more than just the strength of the circ pump to clean a system, and even then there's still no guarantee you'll get everything out. The reps didn't seem to know much about power flushing at all. When I asked them about reversing the flow she said "Why would you need to do that?"

 

[WHPES]

The magnaclean isn't going to remove debris which has already settled out in the system - only chemical cleaning and powerflushing will do that. What it will do is pick up any loose debris suspended in the water.

 

[AFLT]

The magnaclean isn't going to remove debris which has already settled out in the system - only chemical cleaning and powerflushing will do that. What it will do is pick up any loose debris suspended in the water.

Exactly! I think I'll stick with my flusher and my CombiMag.

 

[WHPES]

The people who man the trade stands are salesmen and not plumbers!

 

[spikewt]

Anyone thort about using both. Iv been given a powerflush machine but can't help but think that it's such a pain in the rse getting the dirty water out an also how much water you use doing that. I agree that the system pump won't shift sludge very well. So I'm gonna connect the magnacleanse before the powerflush unit. Best of both worlds. Anyone else done that or think of a reason why it wouldn't work.

 

[ferret]

I got one of the Fernox Magnom powerflush filters (I think it's called the Flush Buddy now or something similar) and it does a good job of cleaning out the magnetic debris. The only complaint is that it can be a bit of a pain to clean out.

Anyone thort about using both. Iv been given a powerflush machine but can't help but think that it's such a pain in the arse getting the dirty water out an also how much water you use doing that. I agree that the system pump won't shift sludge very well. So I'm gonna connect the magnacleanse before the powerflush unit. Best of both worlds. Anyone else done that or think of a reason why it wouldn't work.

Exactly too much stopping to clean out when flushing best way i,ve found is to do a normal chemical flush , then magna clean flush at the end result is crystal clear.

 

[mitchellplumber]

I've been power-flushing for years now and I only bought the Adey MagnaCleanse filter a few months ago. I find it does a really good job and takes a lot of sludge out of the system. I know the feeling with the "pump", I was also very skeptical about this. The thing is, if you clean one radiator at a time the central heating pump is only pushing through one rad (with chemicals) at a time and if you use it with the vibraClean (agitator) this will dislodge the hardened magnetite. Your looking at about 10-15 mins per radiator. The good thing about this system is you are not dumping the water until the end of the process therefor you keep all the cleanser chemicals in the system the whole time.
On one job I had recently though, I did struggle a bit with a blocked feed pipe.... out came the power-flusher and fixed the problem. I would say, its a great piece of kit but would not recommend getting rid of your power-flusher.