Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

Feb 3, 2021
73
15
8
united kingdom
Member Type
DIY or Homeowner
Hi all,

We recently had a ground floor bathroom/wet room finished off, It's about 3.6m long by 2.7m wide, tiled from floor to ceiling and has no window in there due to a future extension that will take place on the other side of the rear wall.

Unfortunately, i've Instantly noticed when showering that alot of condensation is forming on the tiles/mirrors and the room stays really wet and humid in there for hours afterwards, which even with the fact we jackoboarded most of the room....its still giving me cause for concern. As I can see wet patches and mould forming on the grout already just a few weeks in.

As part of the bathroom fit, the spark did install a 4" Mentis, Axial type extractor fan in there (pictured). Though doing a bit of research online i'm thinking that this may be the problem as the fan looks quite weak. It has an extraction rate of 73 m3 per hour....and the ducting it's venting through is about 2.5m long...obviously with a right angle bend in it too.... which i've read could well be too long for this fan too?

Anyway long story short, i'm looking at swapping it out for something much more powerful, ideally without having to change the 4" ducting to 6". In-line types not an option as there's no access to the ceiling cavity without making a big hole everytime it hypothetically breaks down.... so i'm guessing from my basic research online that my best bet is to go centrifugal, or mixed type. Either something like the Vent-axia Lo Carbon Quadra/ Vent-axia lo carbon revive, or Airflow Icon60? all seem to have an extraction rate of 220 m3 per hour, so three times as powerful as what i've got now, so hopefully would solve this issue.

Love to get some input on this, am I on the right lines to solving this? are there other things I should be considering too? and has anyone used any of the models above and can comment on their experience? they're all quite expensive so would like to get it right!


pictures below for reference.

extractor_fan_pos.jpgIMG-0909.JPGIMG-0912.JPGIMG-0911.JPG
 
The first thing you should be considering is, is there enough air getting into the bathroom to replace the amount you are currently trying to extract.
Is there a vent in the wall / door or is the bottom of the door cut to leave a gap, connecting with rooms ouside the bathroom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
I suspect you have a number of issues here

1. how long does the timer stay on for after the lights are switched off ?

2. how big is the gap under the door ?

3. what is the fan vent made of?

4. how is the room heated?
 
thanks for so many replies already folks, already things that i obviously haven't considered such as sucking air from outside the room.

I suspect you have a number of issues here

1. how long does the timer stay on for after the lights are switched off ?

2. how big is the gap under the door ?

3. what is the fan vent made of?

4. how is the room heated?

1) I've left the lights in for 2hrs after a shower to see whether the timer was the issue, still had misty mirrors and water on the tiles and grout / felt muggy when entering the room.

2) slightly undulated, 8mm at the most, 4mm at the worst.

3) looking from the outside of the property back through the external vent, it looks like a tin foil type, so i'd assume a flexible aluminium? It's circular too, not the flat type.

4) Two ways, there's a wall rad on the right hand side between the basin and door. and it has an electrical type UFH too. Though when using the bathroom so far i havent had either of these on.

One other thing i've just noticed, when I hold my hand over the external vent I should feel air coming through there when the fan is on right? obviously I appreciate the stupidity of that question but I'm just not feeling it....it feels slightly warm, but not as if it's blowing onto my hand.
 
Last edited:
The first thing you should be considering is, is there enough air getting into the bathroom to replace the amount you are currently trying to extract.
Is there a vent in the wall / door or is the bottom of the door cut to leave a gap, connecting with rooms ouside the bathroom.
No vent no, hadn't considered this. But I have showered once with the door wide open, didn't appear to make a huge amount of difference.
 
You need a vent / ventilation for the shower area as that fan isn’t doing nothing where it’s positioned

Also supply air is needed
I think it's going to be a little bit of a pain in the backside to do that now. As the ceiling joists run front to back in that room and the channel i'd run the ducting down from the shower will have a whopping soil pipe between that and the external wall... so not even sure its possible. on the attached, blue is the proposed shower vent, green is where the soil is running horizontally.

shower_vent_possible.jpg


That said, most of the moisture is on the other side of the room, the far back side, furthest from the shower... so it's like the vapour is just not being sucked up by the extractor fan as it passes by.....
 
If the red x is where the fan is, it is in the wrong position imho.

it would be more effective over the shower so the air drawn under the door pulls more air through the shower area and out

aNS as the shower has its own ceiling then the air directly above it is unlikely to clear
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
If the red x is where the fan is, it is in the wrong position imho.

it would be more effective over the shower so the air drawn under the door pulls more air through the shower area and out

aNS as the shower has its own ceiling then the air directly above it is unlikely to clear

Yes, I see what you're saying, though I replied to a separate comment about how im not sure thats even viable due to the joists and soil pipe positions... (attached below) blue is proposed fan over shower, green is soil pipe, red is where current fan is. I cant see how i could then duct it to the external wall at the back with the soil pipe in the way like that.

As its unlikely I can get it vented above the shower.... I guess.... where's the next best place for it? even further from the shower would be bad, right?
 

Attachments

  • shower_vent_possible.jpg
    shower_vent_possible.jpg
    241.1 KB · Views: 50
The problem is with the room being on the larger size and not being in the correct / ideal position your going to have to up the output eg increase the dia to increase the air changes in a room

I would say a 6” would struggle 8” would be better as it would change the room air once ever 2-3 minutes
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
The problem is with the room being on the larger size and not being in the correct / ideal position your going to have to up the output eg increase the dia to increase the air changes in a room

I would say a 6” would struggle 8” would be better as it would change the room air once ever 2-3 minutes

Interesting, I cant say i've seen any centrifugal type ones yet that have bigger ducting than 4"....

Plenty of axial types but they're generally less powerful arent they? Icon60 by Airflow was the biggest axial / hybrid type I saw and that was 6" but it got lots of awful reviews. So thought a 4" vent-axia centrifugal might be enough, based on the flow rates they advertise they look pretty powerful to be fair, over three times the extraction im getting currently. Louder ofcourse as the trade-off, but that's not an issue really.


says it'll do 60l per second, vs my current one which does about 19.
 
That's the current ducting, running from the extractor fan to the external wall, running parallel to the joists. Length of duct is thereabouts 2.5M

So why don’t you get the installer back. Cut a new hole in the ceiling and use the duct in place?

Sounds like the installer hasn’t done many bathrooms
 
  • Like
Reactions: ShaunCorbs
So why don’t you get the installer back. Cut a new hole in the ceiling and use the duct in place?

Sounds like the installer hasn’t done many bathrooms

I can get the installer back, but I'm not sure I follow what you mean?

Apologies if ive been unclear, red is what's already there, ducting and fan. My initial idea was to simply swap out the red x marked fan for something much stronger. Till I saw the responses on this thread about moving the position of the fan.

If you mean cut a hole somewhere else, where do you mean?
 
Interesting, I cant say i've seen any centrifugal type ones yet that have bigger ducting than 4"....

Plenty of axial types but they're generally less powerful arent they? Icon60 by Airflow was the biggest axial / hybrid type I saw and that was 6" but it got lots of awful reviews. So thought a 4" vent-axia centrifugal might be enough, based on the flow rates they advertise they look pretty powerful to be fair, over three times the extraction im getting currently. Louder ofcourse as the trade-off, but that's not an issue really.


says it'll do 60l per second, vs my current one which does about 19.

That would give you an air change in roughly 10-12 minutes

Inline ones are always best

 
That would give you an air change in roughly 10-12 minutes

Inline ones are always best


i know, it's just that where the inline one would go, would not be accessible with it being a ground floor bathroom. So not sure I can be arsed with the faff of cutting a hole in the ceiling everytime it needs to come down.

I suppose an alternative would be to do a sort of loft hatch instead..... But even then the rate of extraction isn't heaps beyond 220 M3 per hour.

Not sure it's worth it. as a first port of call anyway!
 
i know, it's just that where the inline one would go, would not be accessible with it being a ground floor bathroom. So not sure I can be arsed with the faff of cutting a hole in the ceiling everytime it needs to come down.

I suppose an alternative would be to do a sort of loft hatch instead..... But even then the rate of extraction isn't heaps beyond 220 M3 per hour.

Not sure it's worth it. as a first port of call anyway!

just get the installer back to relocate the fan to above the shower and use the existing ducting!
 
I would move the fan so it’s over the shower 😁
haha, I know, me too... but I dont think it's an option. Let me do another diagram.

Black lines are the joists,
Blue is proposed position of fan over shower and ducting from shower to external
green is soil pipe that cant be moved because of an RSJ.
red is current extractor and current ducting

extractor_over_shower.jpg
 
Last edited:
haha, I know, me too... but I dont think it's an option. Let me do another diagram.

Black lines are the joists,
Blue is proposed position of fan over shower and ducting from shower to external
green is soil pipe that cant be moved because of an RSJ.
red is current extractor and current ducting


How could he get the current ducting from where it is to the shower if the joists run front to back?

I thought you said the red lines were marking where the vent runs ????????
 
i know, it's just that where the inline one would go, would not be accessible with it being a ground floor bathroom. So not sure I can be arsed with the faff of cutting a hole in the ceiling everytime it needs to come down.

I suppose an alternative would be to do a sort of loft hatch instead..... But even then the rate of extraction isn't heaps beyond 220 M3 per hour.

Not sure it's worth it. as a first port of call anyway!

810m3/h

You were reading the lps movement 🙂
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
Above in my post (20)
Thats beefy indeed. Would mean ripping the ducting out and going bigger but thats not necessarily a bad thing. I reckon it's probably overkill at 800 odd m3 but maybe you're right.

I guess it cant hurt to try a centrifugal one first thats three times the extraction of my current.... and if that doesnt cut the mustard as it were, then I can just go nuclear with an 8'' inline.
 
flexi vent slows the airflow down. Longer runs are far better using soil pipes
Is 2.5m considered long? Ideally I want to try and fix this with the least amount of ceiling coming down as possible.

are some types of flexi better than others? all the inline ones i've got in the loft dont use the aluminium stuff, but they're like a white material instead.
 
Can you push a length of 4” soil pipe in from outside, where your current grill is?
Then connect up a centrifugal fan to that, this would not entail pulling any ceiling down and may be enough to solve the problem.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
Can you push a length of 4” soil pipe in from outside, where your current grill is?
Then connect up a centrifugal fan to that, this would not entail pulling any ceiling down and may be enough to solve the problem.

That is my hope yes. It's an odd layout though this house, it was a bungalow at one point and when extra floors were added they retained the original bungalow ceiling, meaning all the cavities between the ground and first floor.... are not run of the mill haha. I recall it being multi cavitied and all sorts of weird stuff in there.

So I think im gonna try the centrifugal first as phase 1. If not good enough, try change the ducting to solid. If still too wet, then keep the solid ducting and go for an inline one.

Maybe a silly question - but can you run a fan with wider ducting than recommended? I can see how running smaller would cause too much back-pressure. But if I bought a 4'' centrifugal, then one of those 4'' to 6'' converter pieces for the ducting, then ran 6'' ducting..... that would be fine?

Asking because I guess then if I DO swap to an inline in future, a 6'' one would be heaps more powerful.... so seems a better strategy overall.
 
Here’s what I’d do. Remove a tiled column by the bath, replace with hollow structure connected to low level 150mm waste then out through the wall at low level. Slight drop on the 150mm pipe. Plenty of room at side of bath for a beast in-line fan. Replace column and hide a large grill at the top of the back of it.
 
Here’s what I’d do. Remove a tiled column by the bath, replace with hollow structure connected to low level 150mm waste then out through the wall at low level. Slight drop on the 150mm pipe. Plenty of room at side of bath for a beast in-line fan. Replace column and hide a large grill at the top of the back of it.
If shower doesn’t clear you could extract from it just into the main room and let the beast clear it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
100% get rid of flexi duct. I won’t even use it for a meter run.

Considering the room has no windows, I am a bit disappointed that the installer didnt call any of this out.... But hey, no point looking back, best focus on the best way to fix it.

I asked Vent-axia whether there'd be an issue running a 4" centrifugal extractor fan onto a 4" to 6" adaptor, then into 6" ducting. They said not ideal, but fine. So gonna go ahead and buy their Lo Carbon Quadra, and swap the flexi crap, for solid 6" ducting. That will be atleast 3x the extraction rate to my current setup.

If that doesnt sort the problem, then i'll go for the vent-axia 150mm inline ACM. and just install a little loft hatch above the bath for future maintenance access to the inline fan. That will be 11x the extraction rate to my current setup. Though hopefully I dont have to go this far.
 
How are you going to change the ducting?

PS I do think you should talk to the installer so they are aware of the issues you are having, so they can learn

If you think it’s bad now, just wait until the winter
 
How are you going to change the ducting?

PS I do think you should talk to the installer so they are aware of the issues you are having, so they can learn

If you think it’s bad now, just wait until the winter

ducting change will be for the sparks that comes and swaps the extractor fan to the centrifugal.

i'm guessing they will core a larger hole from the exterior wall, tie the new ducting to the old ducting, and push/pull it through hoping it doesn't snag on anything. If it does and the ceiling has to come down to get the bigger ducting in, that's fine cause we'd have to cut a hole to get the in-line up there anyway.

But hoping just the fan change will suffice without changing the ducting, as that's the least intrusive option, obviously.
 
Flexi vent is 100% rubbish on anything other than runs that are short or need to go around corners

concorde was shaped as it was for airflow reasons
 
Update on this one,

So i've had the crappy extractor fan swapped over to a Vent Axia Lo Carbon Quadra, Centrifigual type extractor fan.

At maximum speed setting (220 m3 per hour), it is preventing moisture in the room, but by god is it loud, its deafening when you're in the room at round 50decibels.

Not something i'm going to be able to get used to unfortunately. So i've tried setting it to half speed (110 m3), noise is then a bearable 37db, and it does keep the moisture off the surfaces for i'd say about 5mins of shower time, but anything longer than that the room does start getting quite cloud, as if it that there's just too much vapour for it to deal with eventually. At which point it does start to form on the tiles/mirrors etc.

That said, I left it running after 10-15mins after the shower stopped and after that time, the room is quite dry again.


If it only stays wet in the room for 10-15.... will that still be an issue with damp / mould eventually, or is that OK?
 
Last edited:
I thought you said the red lines were marking where the vent runs ????????

extractor fan swapped over to a Vent Axia Lo Carbon Quadra, Centrifigual type extractor fan.

At maximum speed setting (220 m3 per hour), it is preventing moisture in the room, but by god is it loud, its deafening when you're in the room at round 50decibels.

You haven't been using it for long enough to draw any conclusions - and remember its a warm dry time of year

20 minutes minimum for the over run timer IMHO
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
You haven't been using it for long enough to draw any conclusions - and remember its a warm dry time of year

20 minutes minimum for the over run timer IMHO

Yeah fair enough, I need to cut a hole now anyway as the spark seems to think the ducting vent on the exterior wall has been cored out too low, meaning the ducting wont be running straight acrosss the ceiling cavity but instead will S bend down for some reason. He advised that needs addressing, so we're gonna cut a nice hole over the bath and see about fitting an Inline ACM125T in there instead.

125T is 30db at max speed of 330 m3 per hour. Just a case of whether we've got enough room in the ceiling cavity, but we need to cut the hole anyway now to see whats going on with this ducting regardless so can't hurt to try and fit one in there at the same time!
 
You need to have a steamy shower and see how the fan gets on, then do it again and partly open and see if it clears quicker - if it does then the gap under the door isn’t enough
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
Look at Manrose MF125T, 310m3/hr at 25dB

I’ve used the 4” version a few times when there’s a long ducting run as axial are rubbish unless just pushing through a wall.

Again, I use rigid duct where at all possible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pgeddon
Fwiw concealing an inline fan above the ceiling needs access
Yes, i'll update shortly doing the work now - we've added an access hatch for the ACM 125T Vent axia.

Quick question though - when swapping to the solid 5" ducting, we've found a horizontal piece of timber spanning the joists and it wont allow enough space to get the 5" ducting through.

As an alternative - is the flat/rectangle ducting any good? If so what size is equivalent in performance to 5" round? As that may be our only option short of notching out this piece of wood.... but it means ceiling down if so.
 
Update on this one - Couldn't get the ACM150T in there as there wasn't enough height clearance in the ceiling cavity.

But the ACM125T went in there.... just.... now with 5" solid ducting It's blowing super hard and really not that loud.

No condensation on the walls even during a long shower now, and id say leaving the fan on for about 5 mins post using the bathroom, even the glass shower door was bone dry.

Overkill, perhaps.... but we got there in the end, thanks for all your help.
 
Couple of photos im putting up too before i close the chapter on this one haha.

Forgot to mention when we cut a hole up there and found the old flexible ducting, the installers had nailed an electrical cable to a joist to 'hold' the ducting in place, I presume before the ceiling went up....but the cable was completely throttling it. I guess that explains why the original Axial fan I had did F-all. Certainly wouldn't have helped anyway.

And the other photos, ACM125T neatly in place, solid ducted up and a neat little hatch I made for an access panel should it ever break down in future 😀

thanks again all.

IMG-1413.jpg

IMG-1669.jpgIMG-1670.jpg
 
Not to dampen your enthusiasm for a job well done but until the winter arrives you won't know ho effective the solution is.

Bathrooms need a lot of heat AND ventilation ..................
 

Official Sponsors of Plumbers Talk

Similar plumbing topics

L
Replies
6
Views
1K
Bathroom Advice
Chainsawcharlie
C

We recommend City Plumbing Supplies, BES, and Plumbing Superstore for all plumbing supplies.