Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

HEATING SYSTEM ADDITIVE STATED TO IMPROVE SYSTEM EFFICIENCY AND SAVE APPROX. 15% ON GAS BILLS

View the thread, titled "HEATING SYSTEM ADDITIVE STATED TO IMPROVE SYSTEM EFFICIENCY AND SAVE APPROX. 15% ON GAS BILLS" which is posted in Gas Engineers Forum on UK Plumbers Forums.

The other thing that occurred to me is that efficiency doesn't have a single meaning in science. It's very abstract in the same way that "percentages" or even "numbers" are.
So you could indeed improve the"efficiency" of a radiator or other heat exchanger by 15% (eg by directing a fan over it) but that would be efficiency of heat transfer between the fluids, not efficiency of turning gas into usable heat.

I suspect the technical department proved the former, and the marketing department wrote the latter.
 
I remember reading some QRL (Quinn Radiators LTD) literature in which they claimed their new radiator was more efficient: the small print showed that the new radiator was more efficient in terms of heat output per lb of steel used in the manufacture of the radiator (and therefore the newer design of radiator had less embodied energy for a given heat output), compared with the standard design. By that yardstick, re-using an old radiator would have been even more 'efficient'.
What we really are interested in in terms of efficiency is getting the maximum thermal comfort (minimum percentage of people dissatisfied with the room temperature) for the least possible amount of gas.
 
I remember reading some QRL (Quinn Radiators LTD) literature in which they claimed their new radiator was more efficient: the small print showed that the new radiator was more efficient in terms of heat output per lb of steel used in the manufacture of the radiator (and therefore the newer design of radiator had less embodied energy for a given heat output), compared with the standard design. By that yardstick, re-using an old radiator would have been even more 'efficient'.
What we really are interested in in terms of efficiency is getting the maximum thermal comfort (minimum percentage of people dissatisfied with the room temperature) for the least possible amount of gas.
As johnduffell said, it's worth making sure what somebody means by efficiency.
And if the higher heat output per kg of steel is achieved by using thinner steel hence shorter rad life, overall there might be no improvement
 

Official Sponsors of Plumbers Talk

Reply to the thread, titled "HEATING SYSTEM ADDITIVE STATED TO IMPROVE SYSTEM EFFICIENCY AND SAVE APPROX. 15% ON GAS BILLS" which is posted in Gas Engineers Forum on Plumbers Forums.

We recommend City Plumbing Supplies, BES, and Plumbing Superstore for all plumbing supplies.

Thread statistics

Created
CHRISX,
Last reply from
fixitflav,
Replies
37
Views
12,245
Back
Top