Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Looks like you guys are getting the picture, As with anything that is backed by Government and I am not on about political parties but the beaurocrats, There has been no thoughts to small businesses and one man bands, The physical cost of a one man band, may be installing the odd heatpump the odd solar panel the odd woodburner and so on is prohibitve, How long will it be before we are forced to go through some extorinate scheme to fit bathroom suites and so on.

The one most excellent thing about anything that is backed by beaurocrats is they usualy leave loopholes wide enough to drive 2 x 1 mile long super tankers through sideways, and saying that I am still not MCS accredited because of cost and the endless hoops for paperwork but I am still registering sign offs
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
My take on it ( Sorry quality am already Solar installer)
Lets say you get 300kw of solar heat (anyone any better figures)
You will get 8.5p per Kw for 20 years woweeeeeee works out at £510 over 20 years🙁
Keep your MCS im offering £600 discount today !
Did a twin cylinder solar system evac tube . Big company was £8500 for materials !!!! We did job all in £5500
We plumbers and heating engineers etc must be the stupidest people on this planet yet another drain on us to do the job we can already do !!!!!!

Hi Toddyplumb,

The figures you have presented would not make it attractive for anyone but in reality you would'd be looking at 300kwh a year as this is far too small an average would be more like 2000kwh on a Solar Thermal system and 20,000kwh on a heat pump system.

So lets say the Domestic RHI pays out at double the commercial rate similar to the feed in tariffs on the electrical side. This will mean the following sort of cash back would be expected and this will make it far more attractive to any electrical installation. In addition add on the fact that you could be saving 50% + off your Oil or LPG bill and you are well into the profit.

Ground/Air Source Heat Pump @ 10p/kwh £2,000.00 per year for 20 years + £500 a year savings on an average oil bill? = £50,000 over 20 years and the install cost on air source might be £5,000 - £6,000 and ground source might be £8,000 - £10,000
Solar Thermal @17p/kwh £340 per year for 20 years + £200 a year savings on hot water? = £11,000 over 20 years average install cost £4,000

The whole industry is going to boom on the back of these generous proposals which are needed to get the market to where it should be. Experienced heating engineers like yourselves should be at the front of the line for the work.
 
Hi dontknowitall ,

I will give you a brief rundown on the costs you are looking at for certification. The average cost is £1,100 for an installer to become MCS Certified and then £400 a year to be audited each year. Don't include the ongoing support cost as that is optional if you dont want to maintain it yourself. For £1,100 you have MCS and then £400 a year on top of your other costs to keep your certification. If you needed to go on a course to learn a new technology you are looking at approx £300 for a certified one and that is one off. In terms of day rates if you speak to other installers in the industry i would think your day rate will drastically improve if you are now installing a Solar Thermal installation or Air Source Heat Pump installation where your competition is alot smaller, demand far higher and customers are putting these systems in because of the incentives available, which aren't available in the other markets you are working in. Advertising probably wont even be necessary as most installers get flooded with work because there is a shortage of experienced engineers who are certified to install these technologies.

Your oftec is £160 a year your MCS will be £400 a year? but for £400 a year bringing in 1 heat pump job at £7,000 you will have paid it for the next 5 years+?

I welcome any thoughts.
 
Hi GQuigley67,

Not a problem one thing you can try is start looking into technologies you may easily move into so take heat pumps as an example. Next time your at "Mrs Smiths" and he boiler has packed in and she says how much for a new one and you say £1,000 you could always offer her the alternative of a heat pump system at £6,000 which will earn he £1500-£2000 a year? And she is not dependant on gas which is only going one way? Then once you have a job lined up as your first one you can look into going through the certification process etc?

Always worth a thought as the governments hope is when these boilers do break down people will want to look at renewable alternatives instead of a simple boiler swap?

What are your thoughts?
 
APOLOGIES MCS . You are of course correct , it is 3000 KW , we have a system running with flows and Kw calculations displayed , I missed a zero off DOH !!! So I can actually confirm it is 3000 so £5100 over 20 years .
Now then ......... It is worth serious consideration .
Once again I appologise for my figures , I may well be in touch MCS
Would I be able to claim on my own installation ?
 
Last edited:
Hi EasyMCSLtd

I appreciate the on-going dialogue but I feel we might end up having to agree to differ! However, I'm not giving up easily and want to clarify some matters as well as try and give a picture of how difficult it might be where I live.

Hi dontknowitall ,

I will give you a brief rundown on the costs you are looking at for certification. The average cost is £1,100 for an installer to become MCS Certified and then £400 a year to be audited each year. Don't include the ongoing support cost as that is optional if you dont want to maintain it yourself.

I'm assuming you mean't to say "Don't include the ongoing support cost ... if you want to maintain it yourself."

For £1,100 you have MCS and then £400 a year on top of your other costs to keep your certification. If you needed to go on a course to learn a new technology you are looking at approx £300 for a certified one and that is one off.

I'm assuming this means if I want to do solar thermal and photovoltaic this means an upfront cost of £1,100 (average) plus £300 (thermal) plus £300 (photovoltaic). Am I correct in thinking the £1,100 is the cost of conducting a QMS and are those courses 2-day courses? If one day I'm not sure I'd have learned enough to feel confident of installing the systems.

In terms of day rates if you speak to other installers in the industry i would think your day rate will drastically improve if you are now installing a Solar Thermal installation or Air Source Heat Pump installation where your competition is alot smaller, demand far higher and customers are putting these systems in because of the incentives available, which aren't available in the other markets you are working in. Advertising probably wont even be necessary as most installers get flooded with work because there is a shortage of experienced engineers who are certified to install these technologies.

Sounds a little like a free lunch!!

I'm sorry but there is much rural poverty in the country. According to an article in yesterday's Times newspaper "More than 928,000 rural households live below the official poverty line in struggling towns and villages. In sparsely populated areas, the proportion of low-income households has increased from 26 to 30 per cent in the last two years ... the cost of living in rural areas is £2,600 more than in towns and cities, according to the Office for National Statistics."

These areas are places such as Cornwall, Devon, Herefordshire, mid and east Wales, ***bria. Where I live, the area receives money from the EU and the average salary is 20% below the national average wage.

A cheap plumber round here is £150 a day with a £30 call out and an expensive one is £200 a day with £50 call out. There are not that many wealthy people around as they tend to live in more expensive parts of the country because that is where the well paid work is.

Your oftec is £160 a year your MCS will be £400 a year? but for £400 a year bringing in 1 heat pump job at £7,000 you will have paid it for the next 5 years+?

I welcome any thoughts.

In many of these rural areas I can't see many people installing a £7,000 system. There's much talk about and they hear prices of £3,000 or so. Then, when you explain that's just for the renewable bling but doesn't include labour, nor the new hot water cylinder, nor the cost to bring up the water pressure and flow rate to a suitable level etc they are just turned off. (Many rural properties do not have mains water.)

For a salary of £20,000, with £2,000 or so being spent on oil, at least £2,500 spent on motoring costs (no effective rural transport), £5,000 on food, then there's the mortgage, etc it doesn't leave much room for a £7,000 heating system when you still have to keep your oil boiler running for the times the renewable system cannot cope with demand.

I'm not saying it's a waste of money becoming MCS registered but I need to ensure that it will be a profitable investment.

So the cost, as far as I can make out, is £1,100 set up of the Quality Management System.

The course for solar thermal is £300.
The course for photovoltaic is £300.

There is a £400 annual registration cost.

So the first year will cost me £2,100 and each subsequent year will cost me £400.

Are these the ONLY costs? Does this price mean that I can LEGALLY sign off work and my customers can benefit from the feed-in-tarriff or whatever government grant systems there are? Do I have to re-train every so many years?

I am NOT trying to be negative. It is an exciting development in plumbing and one I thought of before I became a plumber. In addition, where I live there aren't that many installations and the population is talking about it so there will be a market. I just want to know the sort of costs and time involved before spending a fair amount of money (bearing in mind that I don't even earn £20,000!)
 
well thought out dkia i am interested in going down this route in the future as well but with the stated costs i don't think i will be able to afford it in the near future.
 
If I can find a market about here for it then I think it would be worth my while investing in it, but there isn't much rich places in Glasgow, although I would like to be one of the only few companies at the forefront offering these installations. I have had a quick look at the solar workshop at my ACS training centre and it does look interesting, bear in mind though that I have just started trading so I don't make enough money yet to go splashing it out on MCS, I already have Gas Safe to pay and public liability insurance which are both in the region of £400, and if I want to take an apprentice on in the future I have to register with SNIPEF which are around £400 a year, then I would need employers liability which is dearer again, and so on. So this all adds up and it is a real pain to be paying all of these costs just to make a living, when you look at other trades where they work hassle free and earn just as much money and dont have to retrain every 5 years to prove competence and have cheaper insurance and the likes of it
 
APOLOGIES MCS . You are of course correct , it is 3000 KW , we have a system running with flows and Kw calculations displayed , I missed a zero off DOH !!! So I can actually confirm it is 3000 so £5100 over 20 years .
Now then ......... It is worth serious consideration .
Once again I appologise for my figures , I may well be in touch MCS
Would I be able to claim on my own installation ?

Hi Toddyplumb,

Just to clarify the p/kwh you are using is based on commercial and residential is most likely to be 100% higher so around 18p/kwh which would give you £10,800 over 20 years + £2000 of savings on hot water production?

Just worth considering.
 
Hi dontknowitall,

I think I may have miscommunicated the costs. Upfront cost for you total to achieve MCS Certification including our time designing your quality management system and getting you to MCS Standards £1100-£1200 then your ongoing cost is £400 for each years audit and approx £150 to be a member of REAL.

That is it so say £1200 then £550 a year. Pleas bear in mind if you are going into a new technology you will need to go on a training course for it (again one off payment only)

Those are the costs involved.

If you have a look at the DECC website they are showing commercial users will see a 12% return and it is widely expected that domestic will see higher, this is on top of high savings off very high oil bills.
 
Hi dontknowitall,

I think I may have miscommunicated the costs. Upfront cost for you total to achieve MCS Certification including our time designing your quality management system and getting you to MCS Standards £1100-£1200 then your ongoing cost is £400 for each years audit and approx £150 to be a member of REAL.

That is it so say £1200 then £550 a year. Pleas bear in mind if you are going into a new technology you will need to go on a training course for it (again one off payment only)

Those are the costs involved.

If you have a look at the DECC website they are showing commercial users will see a 12% return and it is widely expected that domestic will see higher, this is on top of high savings off very high oil bills.

way too expensive, you only have to look in some of the threads on this forum to realise that many of the one man bands are struggling just on gas work alone. The sort of averidge customers that we are all used to dealing with do not have the sort of money to buy this sort of kit, At this moment it appears to be the well off living in the country with detached houses and these people tend to use the larger companies rather than one man bands ( before you all start I know there are exceptions )

When some of the older men on this forum were trained to install heating systems it covered Gas, Oil and Solid fuel central heating systems, Over the last twenty years we have have been forced to become more elitist to the point that we have to pay different bodies to work on systems that we were trained on, now there are new technologies coming in and the whole industry is being splintered even further. Its High time that this stopped A heating engineer is a heating engineer and as I see it there should be just one body regulating the industry and it shouldnt just cover the unit that is creating the heat but also encompass the whole system to a regular standard.

Just out of interest why are my qualifications that I gained as a young man so worthless, Why has the industry become so fractured
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
been following this thread with interest and i'm afraid i have to agree with the lads on this forum that its far too expensive to get to mcs accredited on the off chance that someone has the spare £7000 upgrading their heating installation.....and even dangling the carrot of "you could earn £10,000 back over 20 years if you have this install" would not sway the majority of the public who's boiler has just broken down and they need a quick "as cheap as possible" fix. In fact i think the majority of people in birmingham would laugh in my face if i gave them a quote of 7 grandish. In this current climate it is just not possible.....people just have not got a spare 7 grand floating around to spend.....petrol and diesel will be costing that much a litre soon with the way the government like to rob all of our money
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
totally agree moogwai and also to benefit from these new systems to the fullest extent they have to stay put for the duration and not move! i know some people stay in the same home for life or near as dammit, but other people like to move often. the fees being spoken of are certainly out of my reach for the foreseeable future. hopefully they will come down when accreditation becomes more widespread but somehow i doubt it very much!
 
HI Guys,

You make some valid points, although accreditation costs are at the lowest they are realisticly going to get to, the cost of equipment has a long way to go. The idea is now that the Feed In Tariffs and The Renewable Heat Incentive will drive down equipment prices and mean that you would be looking at comparable costs to boiler replacements as more and more units get installed. With fuel prices on the Up the aim is that consumers will start questioning replacing with a boiler once the technologies are more affordable. If you look at Solar PV since the introduction of the FITTS prices have started to tumble so it wont be long before the heating side follows.
 
HI Guys,

You make some valid points, although accreditation costs are at the lowest they are realisticly going to get to, the cost of equipment has a long way to go. The idea is now that the Feed In Tariffs and The Renewable Heat Incentive will drive down equipment prices and mean that you would be looking at comparable costs to boiler replacements as more and more units get installed. With fuel prices on the Up the aim is that consumers will start questioning replacing with a boiler once the technologies are more affordable. If you look at Solar PV since the introduction of the FITTS prices have started to tumble so it wont be long before the heating side follows.

As I have stated before all well and good for the big companies but no use for one man bands, Also if its any help to one man bands wanting to get MCS accredited Have a chat with companies that have already gone through the tedious rigmarol of getting MCS accredited and ask how they got their paperwork, you may find that is cheaper than companies offering to do it for you!!!
 
As I have stated before all well and good for the big companies but no use for one man bands, Also if its any help to one man bands wanting to get MCS accredited Have a chat with companies that have already gone through the tedious rigmarol of getting MCS accredited and ask how they got their paperwork, you may find that is cheaper than companies offering to do it for you!!!

Hi Guys,

It is fine to speak to companies already with MCS, please be aware though, MCS Inspecting bodies are coming down hard on people who try and use systems adopted by existing MCS organisations as it should be bespoke to how you operate. Also it isn't very often that an existing MCS company will encourage a competitor to enter the market.
 
Hi Guys,

It is fine to speak to companies already with MCS, please be aware though, MCS Inspecting bodies are coming down hard on people who try and use systems adopted by existing MCS organisations as it should be bespoke to how you operate. Also it isn't very often that an existing MCS company will encourage a competitor to enter the market.

surely most companies operate in much the same way therefore what works for one will work for all. the paper trail is much the same as bsi 9001 quality control if you use that system you shouldn't have any problems with mcs.

The thing that pi***s me off is you dont need any plumbing qualifications to be registered as an installer for any renewables so how can mcs be a guarantee of a quality installation when the installer might be good at paperwork but not have a clue about installation.
 
surely most companies operate in much the same way therefore what works for one will work for all. the paper trail is much the same as bsi 9001 quality control if you use that system you shouldn't have any problems with mcs.

Must admit I'd not thought about that.

The thing that pi***s me off is you dont need any plumbing qualifications to be registered as an installer for any renewables so how can mcs be a guarantee of a quality installation when the installer might be good at paperwork but not have a clue about installation.

I think this is where much of my confusion over the MCS has been until I read this. I'd assumed that the QMS was a general view of the renewables industry and how each of the products worked and how they could work together and that you had to do this course before you launched into one of the specific areas. (This scheme applies to new OFTEC technicians who've no oil experience.)

I'd no idea it was simply about administration.
 

Official Sponsors of Plumbers Talk

Similar plumbing topics

We recommend City Plumbing Supplies, BES, and Plumbing Superstore for all plumbing supplies.