Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws

Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

I have to say. They are good but I like the combimag because of the ease of the bypass for emptying. Magnacleanse is still a great product
 
Magnacleanse looks great. But why can’t we just use an existing filter to take the magnetite out?
I mean add your chemicals, turn each rad off in turn, it all goes through the return and through the filter.
I know you get two large magnets with the unit and it may well be quicker, but then again I’m saving myself £450 so seems to make sense.
 
Magnacleanse looks great. But why can’t we just use an existing filter to take the magnetite out?
I mean add your chemicals, turn each rad off in turn, it all goes through the return and through the filter.
I know you get two large magnets with the unit and it may well be quicker, but then again I’m saving myself £450 so seems to make sense.

The small / normal one would get filled up in minutes when cleaning
 
I’m not really sure how you figure that 40-50 times. All the videos I’ve seen on YouTube, there’s not really that much sludge coming out. Or to look st it another way the two large magnets are 4 times the size of a normal size one. If you empty the large magnets once, then your emptying a normal size magnet 4 times.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Ric2013
It’s all relative mate depends how dirty the system is. If your cunning you could pipe a bypass for the magnacleanse and keep the water circulating while you empty the magnet chambers. If you just use a magnaclean you’ll have to stop everything empty the filter put it all back together losing heat and circulation. Utter waste of time. If you’re doing a proper flush it should take a proper amount of time. I don’t believe that a magnacleanse will do it in the time quoted on a dirty system So a magnaclean will be even slower
 
I do respect your points of view, having used the magnecleanse you have one up on me in that regard. However I just can’t help but feel that the publicity that system cleanliness gets within industry, presents a fantastic opportunity for companies such as Adey to take advantage of legislation to make an awful lot of money.
Also, and as a completely separate point. I find it a hard sell to customers living in my area (S. Wales) generally speaking people really don’t care how clean there system is, as long as it works they are happy. Customers are going to have to buy replacement rads anyway, so it actually works out more cost effective for them to buy new rads (a few at a time) than pay for flushing.
 
Yes but we’re also talking cleanliness for a new boiler and no warranty. I’m sorry mate but I completely disagree with you it’s not a hard sell its installing as per manufacturers requirements and not making a headache for yourself when the customers new boiler packs up. You try and do a flush with a magnaclean. See how long it takes you. On a side note I use a kamco powerflush and combimag same principle but you can do a system of tar back to spotless in a day. It’s about using the right tools for the job in my opinion. Not having a go just how I work
 
Look seriously mate, I know you say some of your customers don’t give a toss but I work in some multimillion pound houses and the customer expects you to have the right gear to do it efficiently and correctly. As I said not having a go but I’ve always been taught to use the right tools for the job. Seriously have a go doing a flush with a magnaclean and see how long you’re there
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Rob Foster
Well there’s your difference isn’t it. You’re working for wealthy people who don’t mind spending the money. This gives you the means to re-invest in your business by buying the right tools.
Trust me around here installers tend to employ the ‘3 F’s’ of Boiler install. ‘Fit, fire up and uck off’.
 
Honest though I might buy a magma cleanse. I am actually pretty up on system cleanliness. Some customers are switched on to it. But there are certainly are large number of customers who would rather you just add a bottle of ‘boiler silencer’
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pickwickpick
Communication does help, but it can only go so far. For last couple of years I've been splitting my work/time between Birmingham and a fairly wealthy bit of London and its a completely different mentality. Most of my clients in Brum I have a fight to convince them that its worth spending a bit more now to save in the long run and that cutting corners is a false economy, to the point where I turn down some jobs as i won't put my name to something that I know will not last. Most of the ones down in London its the complete opposite if anything, I'm telling them they're going ott/wasting money, but they don't care/
 
I find it difficult to flush some systems I work on. No valves work, no drain offs, no filter to connect on to and radiators which are so far gone if you hit them with anything heavier than a biro they would crumble into steelobix
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pickwickpick

Official Sponsors of Plumbers Talk

Similar plumbing topics

We recommend City Plumbing Supplies, BES, and Plumbing Superstore for all plumbing supplies.