L
LPC
Honestly I think you'd have to be absolutely mental to choose an Ideal over a Vaillant.
Gas Engineers only CLICK HERE TO VISIT GAS TALK Forum, and CLICK HERE to Join the Gas Talk FB Community. Read more about this in THIS THREAD.
The Cheap Alternative to Power Flush: Checkout PowDer Flush
Welcome to the forum. Although you can post in any forum, the USA forum is here in case of local regs or laws
Honestly I think you'd have to be absolutely mental to choose an Ideal over a Vaillant.
After being an avid vaillant installer for many years and been disappointed i'm an ideal man now. Only vogue tho don't like logics either.
Have you ever fitted a Vogue LPC?
Valliant are crap back up and parts are expensive.. Ideal E type, Mexico, classic,logic, vogue..... Valliant turbo 242 then down hill. Early Eco with rubber hoses and cracked cony connections below hex. G10 fiasco...
Simply not true. Fitted a Plus that had a dodgy loom, customer rang me 3 days after install, Vaillant came out same day and sorted. Yes rubber hoses were a weak point, but very, very easily sorted.Valliant are crap back up and parts are expensive.. Ideal E type, Mexico, classic,logic, vogue..... Valliant turbo 242 then down hill. Early Eco with rubber hoses and cracked cony connections below hex. G10 fiasco...
Fitted the Vaillant 831 when it first came out, i was an advocate...After all the slug probs the rubber hose probs the continual diverter probs the dodgy pump probs the fact they now don't have knobs on the front only elderly unfriendly controls, we've ditched them. Ideal were complete sh**e but there vogue is top draw. i dont like the lower end but you'd have to be mad to like a budget from any manufacturer.
I've fitted both and done the training courses on both, my first choice is still the Vogue.
Reasons i love it:
1. Easy to fit
2. Looks great(some homeowners are that shallow)
3. 10 Year warranty
4. Plenty of space in there, I'd rather a bigger boiler with lots of space than a tiny thing thats a barsteward to work on.
5. 7m head pump, easy control interface(you really need the codes for the vaillant) and light up dials 😀
6. I've got a free ipad to collect from points \o/
Vaillants also have faults but a much bigger company to provide back up
All boilers have or have had their weak points.
Vaillant's hoses & gasket problems. Worcester's splitting plastic parts etc. Glow-worms leaking from everywhere. Baxi Duo-Tec GA, Ferroli being Ferroli etc. etc.
Vaillant's current models have been on the market for around ten years now. Their build quality faults were sorted years ago & they continue to be a rock solid reliable boiler.
The litmus test will be if we can say the same about the Ideal Vogue in ten years time. If so then it will have earn't the right to be mentioned as a rival to the Vaillant in terms of reliability as the Baxi Duo-Tec HEA is.
I recall many creaming themselves about how good the Ideal Logic was several years ago but from what I hear those are suffering many breakdowns as they get older.
Tbh I think boiler spares prices are criminal. I get tired of telling custards how much the repairs are going to cost. When worked out against labour prices, parts are more than labour.Which is never right.
All boilers have or have had their weak points.
Vaillant's hoses & gasket problems. Worcester's splitting plastic parts etc. Glow-worms leaking from everywhere. Baxi Duo-Tec GA, Ferroli being Ferroli etc. etc.
Vaillant's current models have been on the market for around ten years now. Their build quality faults were sorted years ago & they continue to be a rock solid reliable boiler.
The litmus test will be if we can say the same about the Ideal Vogue in ten years time. If so then it will have earn't the right to be mentioned as a rival to the Vaillant in terms of reliability as the Baxi Duo-Tec HEA is.
I recall many creaming themselves about how good the Ideal Logic was several years ago but from what I hear those are suffering many breakdowns as they get older.
Yes, basicly the same boiler (unsurprisingly) just be aware there is no built in bypass on the system vogue.Cos they're easy to install 😉 Is the Vogue system boiler as highly regarded as their combi's seems to be?
If money isn't an issue for the customer I would agree.Honestly I think you'd have to be absolutely mental to choose an Ideal over a Vaillant.
Wow that's some interesting stats. But really we are comparing a Vailant boiler that has been around a while with some minor modifications and an ideal boiler that's fresh of the cad computer having clearly cloned the vailant. The next vailant will give them back the technological edge as soon as they start feeling the pinch of a competitors product outselling them, the designs they have tested and waiting in the wings will be launched and then ideal will take another 10 + years before deciding to clone another superior product. The winning features on the vogue are all things the vailant has and did first.I think that globally, this is true. Ideal has been sold to the Groupe Atlantique, whose turnover is just shy of Euro 1 billion, whereas the Vaillant global turnover is about Euro 2.3 billion.
However, in terms of unit sales in the UK, my understanding is that Ideal have now displaced Vaillant as the No 2 boiler, behind Worcester.
Look into system boiler and cylinder it would be better for the future
Regarding the noise aspect i have fitted both.
To my ear oddly the logic+ seemed the quieter but not a lot in it.0
Reply to the thread, titled "Boiler choice: Ideal or Vaillant" which is posted in Boiler Advice Forum on Plumbers Forums.
We recommend City Plumbing Supplies, BES, and Plumbing Superstore for all plumbing supplies.