Was I right to Turn off this boiler?

[ballandco]

I would have done the same mate,you know if you didnt I.D it ,it would be playing on your mind for ages,so look after yourself .

 

[Floyd]

Isn't this only I'D if it is a room sealed boiler and not an open flue'd boiler?

 

[CES]

It is room sealed

 

[Floyd]

Oh right, Sorry I must have missed something as the only information supplied was old Ideal boiler.

 

[CES]

Sorry, I've probably assumed it was room sealed due to the picture. The open flued models Ive seen,the thermocouples are routed to inside the combustion chamber,the room sealed versions are attached to the front under the gas valve. I could be wrong, didn't mean to sound flippant.

 

[Billy Bob Bob]

its id in both cases the obvious reasons in RS in the case of OF it could technically let more air in for combustion than designed by the manufacture,excess air = wrong flame picture

 

[Floyd]

I'm led to believe from my ex trainer, that if its pulling ok, it's AR. Either way, they get a ticket an no gas to boiler.

 

[Dotty]

ID no question.

I always will err on the side of caution because I would take a carpeting every day of the week for being over cautious rather than end up before 12 of my peers!

Having said that, it is gut wrenching the first time you do ID an installation / appliance. I had a college campus up in Strabane that had LPG joining 50 year old town gas pipework in a basement boiler house then running up a riser to the top floor restaurant. There were too many items borderline AR and borderline ID as well as the obvious (1st stage LPG in a boilerhouse with no detection, no isolation solenoids, no interlocks to the heating panel, no fire protection or gas tight seals between floors up the riser - gridwork only! Pipework supported in the boilerhouse by blue nylon rope etc). I knew that for some of the kids this was the only place they got a hot meal. Even so - ID.

I felt terrible all day.

 

[Billy Bob Bob]

suppose i am lucky i have no hesitation id ing a appliance if its dangerous/dodgy its off,dont think twice,better cold than dead cold

 

[Dotty]

Couldn't agree more there GM. I don't get a tinge of guilt these days either.

 

[CES]

Last one I turned off, the old lady was fine about it, her son on the other hand was calling me all the names under the sun. He asked if I was proud of turning an old ladys heat and hot water off, to which I replied, atleast she would still be breathing in the morning. It turns out he didn't even live in the house but he was quite prepared to let his mother put up with an open flued mexico spilling, setting off the CO alarm (but it isn't really an alarm because the red led was not flashing ?!?.. ).The convincer was when I carried out a Flue flow test to get my point across and filled the hall with smoke, he kind of shut up after that.

 

[CMairiD]

Couldn't agree more there GM. I don't get a tinge of guilt these days either.

My favourite Croppie ID story is: Who guards the guards?.

Gives me a wee chuckle each time I think about it.

 

[Dotty]

Thank you CMairiD

I found out today that the Strabane job I ID'd was originally worked on by the very same guy responsible for the Castlerock deaths last year. Incidently, he and another fitter are currently on bail after having been arrested for questioning.

I couldn't help thinking of this thread and having a wry smile to myself as I thought "Bloody glad I did shut it down now!"

I'll keep you all informed of the outcome.