Hi Guys thanks for all the suggestions, unfortunatley none of them were correct, it turned out that the sight glass at the top of the heat exchanger had gone into the burner causing the the burner to run at very high temp which damaged the gas valve and fan, which is also why it would run with case off but not when on as it got the extra air through the hole left by the sight glass, evidence found was cracked solenoid casing and discoloration, and soot inside fan vanes, hope this helps someone in the future,
thanks to all who replied to original question.
thanks to all who replied to original question.